Tanachira Retail Corporation Public Company LimitedSET: TAN🇹🇭 TH

MD&A · 2024

Overview of Operations

Overview of Operations

For the year 2024, the average growth of the Private Consumption Index was low to negative, while the Group was able to achieve revenue growth of 22.8 % but profit decreased by 22 % mainly due to losses from new overseas investments and accounting adjustments to align with Thai GAAP standards, which are one-time transactions. For the year2024, the Company had revenue from sales and services of 1,736.9 million Baht, +22.8%, and net profit attributable to shareholders of the Company of 130.1 million Baht, -22.0% compared to the same period of the previous year, which had revenue from sales and services of 987.5 million Baht and net profit attributable to shareholders of the Company of 98.4 million Baht.


Segmented Performance Report of the Group for the Year 2024

In 2024, the Lifestyle segment saw a decline in revenue due to reduced sales of the Cath Kidston brand in both Thailand and Vietnam. However, the Pandora brand continued to experience slight growth from the opening of new stores. The profitability potential of the Pandora brand remains strong, while the Cath Kidston brand continues to face losses. As a result, in 2025, the management plans to reduce the number of unprofitable Cath Kidston stores both in Thailand and Vietnam.

The Fashion segment saw strong revenue growth across all brands, particularly Marimekko, which continued to grow with double-digit same-store sales growth. Sales growth also came from new brands such as Ganni and United Arrows, both of which launched operations in 2024. Overall, the fashion brands in Thailand utilized the existing team and resources to generate impressive profits. The decline in profits was mainly due to Marimekko in Singapore, largely resulting from new investments in opening new stores and accounting adjustments to align with Thai GAAP standards.

The Beauty and Wellness segment achieved strong revenue growth through expansion both in Thailand and internationally, particularly in China, where the response has been favorable. However, the HARNN brand's operations abroad still failed to generate profits in 2024, and there were marketing expenses of 26 million Baht for the HARNN brand in China. As a result, the Beauty and Wellness segment recorded a loss of 8 million Baht in 2024, compared to a profit of 22 million Baht in 2023.

The Food and Beverage segment is a new business segment established in 2024 with a significant investment in the Gordon Ramsay brand. For 2024, the Food and Beverage segment generated revenue of 106 million Baht, with 75% or 80 million Baht coming from the Gordon Ramsay brands. However, the segment recorded a total loss of 20 million Baht, which included a 9 million Baht loss from the Gordon Ramsay brands and an 11-million-Baht loss from lifestyle cafes in Thailand and Singapore. Management plans to gradually close all lifestyle cafes in Thailand in 2025, even though some locations, such as the Marimekko Pop Up Cafe at Central Embassy and the Cath Kidston Tearoom at Central World, still have potential for profitability. This decision aims to better allocate resources within the group for the Gordon Ramsay brands, which show strong profitability potential in the short term.

Operating Results & Financial Condition

Operating Results & Profitability

1. Revenue from Sales

The Company' revenue from sales consisted of sales through two main distribution channels i.e. offline and online channel. The offline channel consisted of (1) Concept store (2) Shop in shop and (3) Other offline channel i.e. B2B, event and sales through distributors. Revenue of the Company can be categorized into Business Group including (1) Lifestyle, (2) Fashion, (3) Beauty and Wellness, and (4) Food and Drink. For the year 2023 and 2024, the Group had sales revenues of 1,414.6 million Baht and 1,736.9 million Baht, respectively. Revenue from domestic business accounted for 92% and overseas 8%. Revenue from overseas in 2024 was at 139.5 million Baht increased 49.7 million Baht or 180.7% from 2023.

The Group's overseas revenue grew due to 3 main factors: the establishment of a subsidiary in China to distribute HARNN’s products including expanding its business branches in Vietnam and Singapore. In 2024, the Company’s highest foreign revenue came from Singapore with Marimekko brand that has the potential to generate revenue from high sales per bill and is a brand that meets the needs of daily life for both tourists and locals.

Meanwhile, Vietnam, generates most of the sales from domestic consumers of both HARNN and Cath Kidston brands. Currently, the Company has stores in leading shopping malls in Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi, with 6 branches for each brand, and the average annual sales ratio through online channels on the E-Commerce Platform and Livestreaming is equivalent to offline sales due to the Company's strong network of KOLs.

Sales from Japan have developed a wholesale business and a spa management business to replace closed branch in Kobe. HARNN brand is already widely known among consumers in Japan and enabled the Company to generate good feedback in distributing products through suppliers in various prefectures. . As a result, HARNN brand has been able to expand its market coverage quickly and steadily in the early stages, as well as focusing on marketing and standardizing the service of the spa business through spa management for leading hotels in major tourist destinations.


For new business in China, the Company 2 main sales channels are online and wholesale. After Brand Conference held by the Company in July 2024 with great interest from business partners from China, the Company started to have real sales since late August. Currently HARNN’s products are available at various Cosmetic Chain Store, Drug Store and Specialty Store with around 200 point of sales in 6 provinces i.e. Guangdong, Henan, Heilongjiang, Jiangsu, Zhejiang and Tibet provinces. There are also 2 branches of HARNN Concept Stores at Shanghai and Shenzhen. Online sales is the main channel during the start of business in China and contributed 60% of total Sales through E-Commerce Platform and Livestreaming such as T-Mall, Xiao Hong Shu, Douyin, JD.com, etc.

The structure of revenue from overseas has begun to develop significantly from an average of 2% in 2023 to8% in 2024, driven by the expansion of investments in new businesses overseas since Q4 of 2023 onwards. This includes the expansion of investments in building the Marimekko brand in Singapore and the HARNN brand in China. The growth strategy in the region has been planned alongside Thailand, with a focus on diversifying the risk of relying on revenue from any single brand. A larger overseas revenue base will help create sustainable profits for the Group in the long term.

The revenue structure by business group for domestic and overseas for the year 2024 compared to the same period of the previous year showed an increase in the proportion of revenue from the Food and Beverage group, from 1% to6%, driven by the operation of restaurants in the Gordon Ramsay group. The proportion of revenue from the Fashion group increased from 19% to 23%, due to the outstanding growth of the Marimekko brand, along with the addition of the GANNI and United Arrows brands. Meanwhile, the proportion of revenue from the Lifestyle group decreased from 61% to 52%, with stable growth of the Pandora brand except last 2 month of the year with price increase affecting sales in Q4 and the decline in revenue from Cath Kidston. The revenue growth of the HARNN brand increased by 26.9% from the previous year, which aligns with the strategic plan to further increase the brand's popularity in Thailand. It remains a brand that continues to be popular among the target tourist group.

For the year 2024, compared to the same period in the previous year, sales revenue by distribution channels showed an increase in the proportion of sales through concept stores, rising from 69% to 73%, and a decrease in the proportion of sales through Shop-in-Shop channels, falling from 16% to 13%. This shift has a positive impact on the Group's gross profit in the long run. The increase in the proportion of sales from concept stores is in line with the marketing strategy plan, which reflects an understanding of consumer purchasing behavior. The Group's same store sales growth (SSSG) was at 4%, with the Marimekko and HARNN brands showing outstanding growth, especially HARNN, which performed significantly better despite no significant increase in core tourist numbers. Only the Cath Kidston brand continued to decline, due to both the closure of branches to reduce expenses and the lack of new products, though clear improvement was observed after receiving new products in the middle of the third quarter.


2. Gross Profit and Gross Profit Margin

For the year 2024, gross profits and gross margins improved from the same period last year from (1) an increase in sales revenue through Concept Store (2) controlling discounts to maintain sales at full price and (3) an increase in the proportion of products and services with high gross margins (part of pre-requisite in considering adding new brand in various business groups).The Company place emphasis on brand building, which enables preservation of high gross profit levels and maintain long-term sustainability.

Overall gross profit margin in 2024 is still in the similar level as 2023 at 64-65% indicating the maintenance of sales guidelines according to the Group's policy that sets selling prices effectively to maintain gross profit margin sand not selling at unnecessary heavy discount domestically and internationally.


3. Selling and Distribution Expenses

Selling and distribution expenses consisted of branch employee expense, space rental, depreciation and amortization, marketing expense, commission, branch utility cost, and royalty fee.

For the year 2024, selling and distribution expenses and the ratio of selling and distribution expenses to sales increased mainly due to business expansions which food and beverage business with employees coming in to support the expansion, an increase in expenses related to store expansion locally and abroad, and more marketing to support the launch of new brands, including early marketing spendings in China to prepare for HARNN's business expansion in the second half of 2024, which will be significantly lower in 2025. If considering excluding this one-time adjustment in Q4 2024, the ratio of selling and distribution expenses to revenue of 2024 would be at 39.2%.


4. Administrative Expenses

Administrative expenses included salaries and benefits for office staff, consulting fees and professional fees, depreciation and amortization of the head office and office rent.

For the year 2024, the Company reported administrative expenses of 256.7 million Baht, increased 75.5 million Baht or 41.7% compared to the same period last year. This is mainly due to an increase in the number of employees in the support department at the head office,additional office space rental to support the growth of the organization, and the write-off of assets of HARNN in Japan. Nonetheless, the ratio of administrative expenses to sales for the year 2024 increased slightly compared to the year 2023.


5. Finance cost

Finance cost consisted of interest incurred on loans and the recognition of interest on lease liabilities from accounting records according to Accounting Standard No. 16. Liabilities under lease contracts, which were included in Q42024 with a value of 3.3 million Baht representing 43.4% of total finance cost. After the initial public offering (IPO) in October 2023, finance costs were reduced significantly. Interest expenses in 2024 decreased from 2023 by 46.9%.


6. Effective Tax Rate

Effective Tax rate is the percent of corporate income tax expense for the period on its net accounting profits before tax. The corporate income tax expense consists of income tax for the period calculated according to the Revenue Department criteria and deferred tax recognized in profits and loss account. Effective Tax Rate in Q42024 increased mainly from income tax of (1) revenue from more sale to HARNN Global Co., Ltd. to HARNN Greater China Co., Ltd. (2) Deferred tax from Timing Difference items, i.e. Amortization – Goodwill and Right of Use (ROU – Depreciation) from the expansion of branches. The investment in shops expansion in this period is considered the new cycle of investment which indirectly affected calculation of deferred income tax compared to the previous year. In addition, the basis for calculating the actual tax rate is derived from the net profit of the consolidated financial statements, which is different from the net tax profit.


7. Net Profit and Net Profit Margin

For the year 2024, the Company had a net profit attributable to the shareholders of the company of 130.1 million Baht and net profit margin in the year 2024 wasat7.5%, decreased from the same period last year mainly due to selling, marketing and administrative expenses increased significantly compared to previous year to support future growth of the business locally and internationally in the long term. If excluding the onetime accounting adjustment of 27.7 million Baht, net profit would be at 157.8 million Baht and net profit ratio would be at 9.1%.

Liquidity & Capital Adequacy

The cash flow statement for the year 2024 showed positive net cash from operating activities of 247.1 million Baht, indicating that the business generated good cash flow. Net cash used in financing activities was mainly from payment of principal portion of lease liabilities and dividend payments of 60 million Baht. Cash and cash equivalents as of 31 December 2024 were at 146.2 million Baht.

Asset Management Capability

1. Assets

As of 31 December 2024, the Company had total assets of 2,725.0 million Baht. The main assets of the Company consisted of (1) Goodwill, (2) Inventory, and (3) Right-of-use assets, which together accounted for 67.3% of the total asset value.

As of 31 December 2024, the Company’s total assets increased 422.8 million Baht compared to the end of 2023 or 18.4% increase mainly from the increase of (1) Inventory which involves increasing the reserve of finished goods to support sales growth, especially for branches/sales channels opening at the end of 2024 and the beginning of2025, with a value of 29.7 million Baht, including packaging and finished goods of the HARNN brand to support delivery to subsidiaries in various countries (2) right-of-use assets from branch expansion, and (3) other non-current assets from the increase of deposit for branch expansion.


2. Liabilities

As of 31 December 2024, the Company’s liabilities were 1,088.7 million Baht. The main liabilities of the Company consisted of (1) liability under lease agreement, (2) trade and other payables, and (3) short-term loan from financial institution, altogether accounted for 85.1% of total liabilities.

As of 31 December 2024, the Company’s liabilities increased 335.9 million Baht compared to the end of 2023 or 44.6 % mainly from an increase in short-term loan from institution in the form of Trust Receipt, trade and other payables and liability under lease agreement following store addition.


3. Equity

As of31 December 2024, the Company’s total shareholder’s equities were at 1,636.3 million Baht increased 87.3 million Baht from 31 December 2023 due to an increase in retained earnings. The company paid a total dividend of 60.0 million Baht in 2024.

Debt Securities with Financial Ratio Requirements

Debt Securities with Financial Ratio Requirements Issued?

No

Factors That May Affect Financial Condition

Factors or Incidents That May Materially Affect Financial Condition

With the goal of building a consistent and sustainable revenue base for the long term, the Group continues to focus on investing in building the brands it manages, building more store locations in major key cities or strategic locations both in Thailand and internationally, while recruiting and increasing number of talents to support the already diversified business groups at the same time. As a result, increases in selling and administrative expenses are inevitable in the short term and it also has an indirect effect on the calculation of the effective tax rate as mentioned in Section 7 above. The management adjusted the branch expansion plan and the increase in expenses to be in line with the seasonality of generating revenue and profits in 2024.

However, the management of the Group has re-evaluated the strategy and investment plans for 2025, and implemented stricter measures to reduce expenses both domestically and internationally. Additionally, the Group will increase the evaluation of each new project’s performance before starting and will terminate unprofitable projects more quickly in 2025. The details are as follows;

1. Adjust the annual investment plan to reduce from 2024, focusing more on investments in projects with quicker returns, and set a new investment budget framework at 4% of total revenue. At the same time, total revenue is still projected to grow by no less than 20%, which will directly reduce the ratio of expenses to revenue and help restore profitability.

2. Expense control across all departments, particularly for new ventures such as the food and beverage business, ensuring that expenses adhere to or are below the budget.

3. Reduce losses from unprofitable businesses, such as:

3.1 Gradually close Cath Kidston branches with high rental costs that exceed the revenue potential of those locations. Management has instructed the relevant teams to communicate with affected employees in advance, offering them the option to transfer to other branches.

3.2 Gradually close Cafe and Tearoom branches to reduce losses, and communicate with affected employees in advance to provide them with the option to transfer to the Gordon Ramsay brand businesses.

3.3 Focus on increasing sales in the international business segment, stop new investments in countries that are still not profitable or require further adjustments to their revenue-generating plans, and strictly control expenses to reduce losses compared to 2024.

3.4 Revise the organizational structure of the international business segment again to align its work standards with those of the head office in Thailand, including increasing personnel and expanding the roles of staff at the head office to provide stronger oversight of international operations.

4. Revise the operation plans of the food and beverage business segment to enhance expense controls, reduce waste, and improve the efficiency of procurement management. Additionally, control staff expenses in line with short-term revenue generation.

5. The directions for implementation of Digital Transformation strategies, such as the Line CRM with Rewards Program, Real-Time Marketing Automation with AI, and Business Intelligence, will enable better integration of all business segments, increasing sales and reducing dependence on marketing expenses that do not directly contribute to sales. This will lead to higher and more sustainable profitability in the long term.

Furthermore, the Group continues to focus on increasing the number of brands to diversify income sources, reducing reliance on any single brand or business segment. In 2025, the Group plans to launch two new brands in the lifestyle and fashion segments within the country. By controlling expenses through reduced new investments, increasing foreign sales, and closing unprofitable branches, the management of the Group is confident that there will be a significant improvement in performance in 2025 compared to 2023 and 2024.

Contents